My bathroom isn’t the cleanest one around, but it isn’t the dirtiest either. Last month, however, my bathroom was treated to a once over like never before, for several days it shined and basked in the glory of cleanliness. I can thank former President George Bush for these few days where nary a loose hair resided in my bathroom.
October 24th, 1992. The day that President Bush senior signed into law the Energy Policy Act which put a 1.6 gallon limit on residential toilet flushes. The progressive thinkers of our country gave themselves a collective pat on the back, and then proceeded to get out their plungers to fix the millions of clogged toilets that spread like the black plague across the US.
So it came as no surprise to me last month while plunging my toilet that what I was seeing was the law of unintended consequences in action! Here we have Congress caving to environmental concerns by passing a law limiting the amount of water we can flush down our toilets. That’s OK though; We can get around this problem by holding down the flusher for a few seconds to clear the plumbing. In fact, I think the “courtesy flush” originated as an additional flush prior to finishing up on the toilet so that it would not clog by trying to flush everything at once; A courtesy to whoever might need to mop up the bathroom floor.
I could have followed any of these guidelines last month when my toilet clogged itself from the woefully inadequate 1.6 gallon flush, but my failure to act led to an hour long session of mopping, bleaching, cleaning, and sanitizing so that I would feel safe to walk barefoot on my bathroom floor again.
How much water would have been saved from multiple flushes, clogging, and cleaning if this law had never been passed? We may never know.
-Joe
Yeah, the multiple flushes thing is lovely for sure. With seven people in the house (and until two years ago, only one bathroom) the toilet got flushed twice at least half the time. Boy, THAT really saves water.
Thankfully, in one of our bathrooms in this house, we still have an old-fashioned “real” toilet. It’s also still in good condition.
Yep, with the 1.6 gallon flushes we now have double or triple flushes in order to clear the residue thus eliminating the savings intended by the single 1.6 gallon flush!
I haven’t seen anyone write on the Law of Unintended Consequences in ages. This was one of the strongest conservative lines of attack in the 70s and 80s. Liberals gain support by talking about the wonderful things government programs will do. Conservatives can best compensate for this advantage by pointing out all the things it’s screwed up in the past. One of our biggest problems now is that “compassionate conservatives” and other Republicans share the naive liberal faith in government efficacy. . .
Wow - this is cutting edge.. what’s next? Complaints that florescent bulbs flicker when you turn them on? Leaded gas costs more than unleaded? First of all, a courtesy flush has nothing to do with clogs - it’s when you flush just as your deposit hits the water, to cut down on the odor. Second, nearly all low-flow toilets allow for two kinds of flushes - if you hold the little handle down, more water is used.
Relax, CGC. My definition of the courtesy flush was only a bit of sarcasm that you seemed to miss. Thanks for reading, though!